Scottish Dress

Prince Charlie vs. Other Kilt Jackets: A Comparison

Kilt jackets are jackets designed specifically to be worn with kilts. They are different from standard jackets in size, material, and design. Since a single kilt jacket does not fit every occasion, they are available in several variations today and they have distinct properties. This article is a comparison of different kilt jackets. it also aims to help you determine which jacket should be your top choice. So, let’s begin our discussion with understanding the kilt jacket itself.

Understanding Different Types of Kilt Jackets

Kilt jackets are primarily made with high-quality wool, which offers comfort, durability, and warmth. They are more ornate than the standard ones. They usually feature details like satin lapels, velvet trim, and shaped pockets and cuffs.

There are several types of kilt jackets available, including Prince Charlie, Argyll, and Tweed styles. Each jacket has a unique appearance, while its ornaments are also different. Similarly, all of them are suitable for multiple events. Detailed information about each type is provided below to help you understand their differences.

Prince Charlie Jacket

prince-charlie-jacke
prince-charlie-jacke

An Overview of Origin

Prince Charlie Kilt Jacket is a formal Highland dress jacket that emerged in the early 20th century as a coatee. Over time, it gained popularity, became known as the Prince Charlie jacket, and became an alternative to the doublet. It got this name because of its connection to the Rebellion leader Prince Charles Edwards.

Design Features

When it comes to the design and features of this particular apparel, it is highly decorative compared to others. It features peaked lapels usually made with contrasting fabric. It is a double-breasted jacket with a tail at the back. The tail has 8 buttons, offering an exceptional look. Wearers get a cuff on both arms, while sleeves are decorated with 3 buttons each. Similarly, the same number of buttons exists on both sides of the front, providing eye-catching visuals.

Material Choices

Similar to traditional kilts, Prince Charlie Jackets are made with wool. Therefore, they are made from a special wool variation called barathea The standard colours of these jackets are black and dark blue.

WeddingsGraduation Ceremonies
FuneralsCorporate Settings
Black Tie EventsFormal Dinners

Argyll Jackets

Argyll Jackets
Argyll Jackets

Origin of Jacket

Argyll Kilt Jackets are traditional ones worn during the 16th century. Highland warriors used them then, while their fame increased in the 17th century. Their area of origin is Argyll, an important region of Scotland because of its diverse culture. Thus, it is the reason to adopt this name.

Exceptional Features

This versatile jacket blends history and modernism at the same point. Argyll Jackets come in many colours and have classical appearances. Usually, they are single-breasted apparel having a single button on the front offering unique visuals. Pockets on both sides and sleeves are fabricated with metal buttons. They do not have tails at the back while the shoulders have straps.

Material That Makes Argyll Jackets

Argyll jackets are also made with barathea wool like the Prince Charlie Jackets. Barathea wool is a luxurious and durable fabric characterized by a tight, twill weave and a smooth, slightly pebbled surface. Therefore, its features like thermal insulation, breathability, and warmth make it suitable for Highland weather conditions.

Pairing with Different Kilt Outfits

We have already stated that Argyll kilts are suitable for formal and semi-formal events. This means an individual can wear it at weddings, Highland Games, Scottish festivals, etc. Undoubtedly, understanding the occasion is essential, and knowing which accessories to pair with the jacket is equally important. Here are some essential attachments:

Kilt ShoesWaistcoat
Kilt ShirtSporran
Hose and Garter FlashesKilt Pin
Chrome BuckleLeather Belt

Tweed Jackets

Tweed Jackets
Tweed Jackets

Origin of Jacket

Tweed Jackets are a traditional part of Highland wear, first worn during the 18th century in rural Scotland. Originally used by farmers and hunters, their popularity spread due to their durability and warmth. They are named after the River Tweed, which flows through the Scottish Borders, where the fabric was first produced.

Exceptional Features

Tweed jackets are a classic and practical option for Highland dress. They come in earthy tones and patterns like herringbone and check. These jackets are usually single-breasted with one or two buttons on the front. Metal buttons are often seen on cuffs and pockets. They have a regular cut without tails and may feature epaulets for a traditional touch.

Material That Makes Tweed Jackets

Tweed jackets are made from heavyweight wool woven in a rough, flexible texture. Tweed is known for being wind-resistant and insulating, which makes it perfect for outdoor wear in colder climates. Its natural fibers also offer breathability and comfort.

Pairing with Different Kilt Outfits

Tweed jackets are best for day events and outdoor gatherings. They are ideal for casual weddings, Highland Games, hunting trips, or countryside events. To complete the outfit, key accessories are important, such as:

A Plain Collar or Ghillie Shirt5 Button Waistcoat with Matching Color
5 or 8 Yard Traditional Tartan KilkDay Sporran with Modern Ornaments
Ghillie BroguesKilt Hose with Kilt Matching Color

Prince Charlie vs. Argyll vs. Tweed Jackets

FeaturesPrince Charlie JacketsArgyll JacketsTweed Jackets
OriginEarly 20th century; linked to Prince Charles Edward16th century; originated in Argyll, Scotland18th century; rural Scotland, near River Tweed
Historical UseFormal Highland dress alternative to doubletWorn by Highland warriors; evolved into formal wearUsed by farmers and hunters for durability and warmth
FormalityHighly formalFormal and semi-formalSemi-formal to casual
MaterialBarathea WoolBarathea WoolTweed Wool
Best Worn ForWeddings, graduations, black tie & formal dinnersWeddings, Scottish festivals, Highland GamesDay events, outdoor weddings, countryside occasions
Typical AccessoriesDress sporran, bow tie, kilt hose, ghillie broguesKilt shoes, waistcoat, sporran, belt, kilt pinGhillie shirt, waistcoat, day sporran, brogues

Considerations to Buy Kilt Jackets

Now that you’re familiar with the features, history, and materials of each jacket style. It’s time to make a practical choice and purchase the one that best suits your needs. Remember, learning and applying are different things. So, while buying a jacket, be sure to consider the following factors.

  • The first thing is to confirm the event where you need to put on the jacket because the theme of the event helps you decide.
  • The next factor you must keep in mind is checking the environment. Tweed is warmer than wool, while wool offers more comfort. So, do not oversee fabric’s nature.
  • Consider your personal preference if the event’s theme allows flexibility. It depends on your choice whether you prefer a double-breasted or single-breasted jacket. Similarly, the apparel’s colour must be what you choose or prefer.
  • The last but most important factor is to examine the practicality. If you need to keep your things along with you, go for tweed or Argyll jackets because Prince Charlie jackets do not have pockets.

Exploring the Range of Kilt Jackets

Now it’s time to explore some high-quality jackets that are worth considering. UtilityKilt UK has a wide range of kilt jackets in every variation. Some of them are given below with prices:

Prince Charlie Jackets

Argyll Jackets with Prices

Argyll JacketsPrices
Navy Blue Argyle Kilt Jacket with Vest£101.11
Tweed Argyll Jacket with Vest£102.70
Tweed Argyll Kilt Jacket With Vest£98.75
Mens Black Argyll Jacket with 5 Button Vest£102.70

Tweed Jackets

Final Thoughts—Which Jacket Should You Choose?

While all of the jackets discussed above have different appearances and traits, your choice should depend on the occasion and your personal preferences. You should choose the Prince Charlie jacket if attending a strictly formal event like a wedding, black-tie dinner, or graduation. For more versatility and practicality, opt for the Argyll jacket. It is ideal for both formal and semi-formal occasions, offering pockets and comfort. Lastly, if participating in any outdoor or colder weather, the Tweed jacket is best with its warmth and charm, making it perfect for countryside gatherings or daytime celebrations.

UtilityKilt UK: Your Destination for Premium Kilt Jackets

Have you decided which kilt jacket suits you best? That’s great to hear! You must consider visiting a store that offers premium quality at the lowest price ranges. Thus, we assure you that no one can compete with UtilityKilt UK in this situation. Not only these factors but we also provide our customers with excellent return and exchange policies. Above all, our inventory is more than just kilt jackets because we offer everything like kilts for men and women with essential accessories.

What is the most formal kilt jacket?

Prince Charlie kilt jackets and Argyll jackets are suitable for formal events, while Prince Charlie dominates here because it is not suggested for casual events at all.

Though this jacket is only suitable for formal events, it can be worn at daytime events like weddings and graduation ceremonies.

All jackets are suitable for cold weather, but tweed wool is known to be the best choice for such conditions. Therefore, other jackets involve barathea wool, which is a less warm fabric.

Argyll jackets serve as a strong contestant for both formal and semi-formal events. So, an individual can confidently wear this jacket variation.

Related Articles

Back to top button